Antique Jewelry physical store.

Top 10 Antique Jewelry Stores in the US

The allure of vintage and antique jewelry is such that it is hard to resist. Fine jewels display the beauty of workmanship that is timeless and tell stories of a bygone era. Even the most simple of ensembles are instantly elevated to a whole new level of chic thanks to the attention-grabbing patterns. Let’s dive into the top 10 Antique Jewelry Stores in the US.

Finding a trustworthy jeweler is the first thing you should do to find the old gem of your dreams. Even though you might think you need to go shopping in person, many well-known galleries and shops sell a wide range of antiques online. Gemologists and historians often work for these sellers and look at each piece to ensure that only the best jewels end up on their well-curated websites.

These websites will help you start collecting antique jewelry, whether you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind engagement ring or a necklace from the Victorian era that will make a statement. Find out where to buy the best old and antique jewelry by reading on.

  1. Estate Diamond Jewelry
  2. Simone & Son
  3. Doyle & Doyle
  4. M.S. Rau Antiques
  5. Sotheby’s
  6. Macklowe Gallery
  7. Keyamour
  8. Erica Weiner
  9. Michael F & Company
  10. Facets

1. Estate Diamond Jewelry

Estate Diamond Jewelry rings in the table and in a hand of a buyer

Our top one is Estate Diamond Jewelry, which has been in business for more than 40 years in the middle of New York City’s Diamond District. A family runs this business, and they only offer old and antique rings that have undergone careful selection and examination.

It has a huge collection of old rings and earrings from the 1880s to the 1970s. It’s free to ship items overnight with insurance, and they have a 14-day return policy that covers all jewelry throughout our collection, no questions asked.

Location: 608 5th Ave., Suite 503, New York, NY 10020

Prices begin at $600

Best for: Vintage rings and Earrings


2. Simone & Son

Simone & Son Showroom Necklace

At Simone & Son, they know that every piece of jewelry you buy is a way to show your love and appreciation for the people in your life who are most important to you. They think that every customer who makes this choice—whether it’s for a wedding, an anniversary, a birthday, or some other special event—takes home an heirloom that will be passed down from generation to generation. Their way of thinking isn’t just about stuff. Each piece comes from their family to yours.

Their skilled artisans, precise gemologists, and creative designers demonstrate their commitment to perfection. Master craftsmen with decades of experience delicately shape raw materials into works of beauty. Gemologists select only the finest stones for their creations. By combining classic art with modern aesthetics, the designers, driven by innovation, create intriguing pieces that blend the past and present. These specialists are Simone & Son’s foundation, infusing every piece with outstanding craftsmanship, vast knowledge, and a dedication to making timeless jewelry.

Location: 10124 Adams Ave., Huntington Beach, CA 92646

Prices begin at $575

Best for: Engagement Rings and Wedding Bands


3. Doyle & Doyle

Doyle and Doyle Show room rings and necklaces

Two sisters who loved gold all their lives started Doyle & Doyle. Today, every engagement ring in its used collection is hand-picked. It also has a large selection of antique, estate, and old jewelry, as well as jewelry for kids and gifts under certain price ranges. You can get free standard shipping within the US, use Affirm to finance your purchases, and put a piece on hold with a 25% payment.
You can get free standard shipping within the US, use Affirm to finance your purchases, and delay a piece with a 25% payment.

Jewelry isn’t just something you wear. Authentic vintage, antique, and estate jewelry can be likened to time capsules that hold the spirit of bygone eras; to memorialize our love stories; and to add to not only our outfits but also our personalities. It is Doyle & Doyle’s goal to help our customers enjoy these parts of old and antique jewelry.

Location: 41 Union Square W, New York, NY 10003

Prices begin at $985

Best for: Art Deco & Edwardian Jewelry


4. M.S. Rau Antiques

M.S. rau Antiques outside post

M.S. Rau, a famous North American fine art, antiques, and jewelry gallery, started in 1912. Bill Rau, the gallery’s third-generation owner, gathers international items for both public and private collections. The 40,000-square-foot showroom features carefully selected works from a variety of artists and artisans who have shaped fine and decorative arts for millennia. Claude Monet, John Singer Sargent, Rembrandt van Rijn, Tiffany, Paul Revere, Thomas Chippendale, Louis Comfort Tiffany, and René Lalique.

M.S. Rau’s jewelry boutique continues the gallery’s century-old tradition of excellence. Rau’s expert gemologists chose designer pieces and huge stones from important mines for their premium jewelry and gemstone collection.

M.S. Rau has held museum-quality displays annually in its New Orleans gallery and at major art and antique fairs for a decade. Rau’s acquisition pros can identify the best works because of these initiatives’ global reach. Additionally, the gallery’s 50 professionals offer the most logistical and financial aid during acquisitions. Professional researchers at Rau check each product for quality and authenticity.

Location: 622 Royal Street, New Orleans, LA 70130

Prices begin at $1850

Best for: High jewelry and one-of-a-kind gemstones.


5. Sotheby’s

Sotheby's showroom necklaces

Since its founding in 1744, Sotheby’s has been the world’s most famous place for art and luxury. Through auctions and buy-now outlets like private sales, e-commerce, and retail, Sotheby’s makes it easier for people to get and own unique works of art and luxury items. Their reputable global marketplace has access to the top technology in its industry as well as a network of experts from 40 nations and 70 categories, including Old Masters, Contemporary Art, Chinese Works of Art, Jewelry, Watches, Wine and Spirits, Design, Collectible Cars, and Real Estate. Art and culture have the power to change lives, and Sotheby’s is dedicated to making these fields more open, long-lasting, and collaborative.

Sotheby’s is still a name that people associate with new ideas. In addition to auctions, Sotheby’s also has a BuyNow marketplace, Sotheby’s Financial Services (the only full-service art lending company in the world), and Sotheby’s Advisory.

In 2019, 31 years after it became a public company, a new era began. A media and telecom billionaire named Patrick Drahi bought Sotheby’s and turned it into a private company again. They chose Charles F. Stewart to be the CEO so that they could deal with the challenges of the modern art market and look for new possibilities.

Location: 1334 York Avenue, New York, New York 10021

Prices begin at $350

Best for: One-of-a-kind ring and Necklace


6. Macklowe Gallery

Macklowe Gallery Showroom Chair and lamp

Macklowe Gallery is the largest authenticated Tiffany lamp and museum-quality 20th-century decorative arts vendor. For more than 50 years, scholars, museum curators, and collectors have sought our knowledge of French Art Nouveau furniture, Tiffany lamps and glass, and fine jewelry. Their gallery validates the authenticity of our pieces, which are chosen for their artistic value, distinctiveness, and historical significance. Over 6,000 square feet of gallery floor space on Park Avenue lets us display one of the world’s most important and complete collections.

Benjamin and Hillary Macklowe have refocused Macklowe Gallery on fostering young creative collectors. Christie’s, Sotheby’s, and appraisal industry events include industry expert Ben Macklowe. Ben, Hillary, and the gallery’s curatorial team have written industry-standard Art Nouveau sculpture and jewelry books.

Location: 445 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10022

Prices begin at $850

Best for: Fine jewelry from the retro period.


7. Keyamour

Keyamour 3 rings

Keyamour is a beautiful group of old, rare, and retro jewels. Care has been taken to pick each piece for its beauty, charm, and collectibility.

Most importantly, these old gems were picked out for today’s women. There is furniture from the Georgian era, the Victorian era, the Art Deco era, the Retro era, and the mid-century modern era in our collection.

They have nice signed pieces from Van Cleef & Arpels and Cartier, and sometimes they mix them with cool Victorian earrings or bracelets. Keyamour is style and fashion. Old and new come together to make something stylish and personal.

Keyamour only sells real items from that time. People who buy can be sure of quality and proper checking. We know how important value and beauty are because we’ve worked in both auctions and fine stores.

Location: 608 Fifth Ave Suite 710, New York, NY 10020

Prices begin at $3250

Best for: Tiffany pieces to Georgian-era brooches and necklaces.


8. Erica Weiner

Erica Weiner Antique jewelries arrow, pendant and rings

Originally introduced in 2007, Erica Weiner’s eponymous brand featured handcrafted pieces that were influenced by historical silhouettes. As the early 2010s progressed, Weiner and her business partner Lindsay Salmon started putting together a collection of antique jewels. They swiftly shifted their focus to selling these one-of-a-kind treasures. At the present time, the brand is well-known for the items that it sells, which include humorous modern pieces in addition to rare antique jewelry that dates back to the 17th to 20th century.

Location: 1425 SW 20th Avenue Suite 203 Portland, OR 97201

Prices begin at $800

Best for: Engagement ring.


9. Michael F & Company

Michael F & Company showroom necklaces

Jewelry is a classic and personal way to show love that can have a huge effect on someone’s life. They make handmade, elegant, and unique engagement rings, wedding bands, and other fine jewelry at Michael F. & Company that really show how much you love and care for someone. They have been in the New York Diamond District for more than 25 years, so we know everything there is to know about diamond wedding jewelry. Andknow how hard it can be to find the right piece of fine jewelry for a special occasion. That’s why we work hard to make shopping with us easy and smooth.

They are dedicated to making sure that every piece of diamond jewelry we make is the best it can be. The engagement rings and wedding bands that our artists make by hand are not only beautiful, but they are also unique. We are proud to be different from our competitors by offering the best workmanship and customer service. We can help you find the right diamond jewelry to show your love and make your special moment one you will never forget.

Location: 7 West 47th Street, Diamond District, New York City 10036

Best for: Engagement rings and Wedding Bands.


10. Facets

facets treasure chest with jewelries

Facets Fine Jewelry is the place to go for high-end jewelry in Park Slope, Brooklyn. The store, which opened in 2000 as a 500-square-foot boutique selling designer pieces, minimal antiques, and sterling silver jewelry, has since expanded into a 3,000-square-foot luxury jewelry and watch store. Facets Fine Jewelry has built a reputation for offering high-end clients stunning jewelry, innovative bespoke designs, rare watch collections, and excellent customer service.

Owner and lead designer Irina Sulay takes this business personally. Irina was designed as a child. After sketching as a child, she became interested in graphic design as a teen, playing with Photoshop and Illustrator. Irina switched from selling independently made jewelry to designing all Facets Fine Jewelry items in 2018 after mastering her technique with time and focus. Irina and the Facets Fine Jewelry team also give design direction in their custom design section, allowing clients to collaborate on unique items or have Irina and her crew dream their perfect heirloom.

Location: 99 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Prices begin at $26

Best for: Fine Handcrafted Jewelry.


Final Thoughts

Looking through the top 10 antique jewelry stores in the US is like taking a fascinating trip through time and skill. These businesses, which are known for their history and authenticity, put together a wide range of collections that show off the fine craftsmanship of bygone times. They are dedicated to being open, educating customers, and protecting the environment, and they provide a unique and individual shopping experience.

These shops do more than just sell jewelry. They also help the community and know how to work in the digital age. Each visit is like a trip through time, where the allure of the past meets the needs of the present. This ensures that they will always be known as the keepers of beautiful old jewelry.

Click here for more.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I’ll visit one of these places soon.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x